Skip to main content Skip to search Skip to main navigation
+49 4122 7084 Contact

Growth problems with roses in flowerbeds: Why planting roses on top of roses rarely works

Roses often grow poorly in spots where roses were previously planted. This so-called growth depression occurs throughout the entire rose family (Rosaceae), for example, even when roses are planted in spots where apples, pears, or raspberries once grew.


Typical signs: 

  • Stunted growth: Newly planted plants have great difficulty taking root. The young shoots develop poorly.

  • Poor flowering: Few or no flowers form.
  • Stunted roots: The root system remains short, dense, and resembles a paintbrush.

Causes:

The main reasons are:

  • High nematode density: Microscopic roundworms (nematodes) have multiplied in the soil and are damaging the new roots.
  • Self-toxicity: The previous plants have released specific metabolic byproducts into the soil that actively inhibit the growth of new rose plants.

Measures:

If you’d like to replant a rose in the same spot, we recommend the following strategies: 

  • Replace a generous amount of soil: Dig up the soil at the old location to a depth of at least 50 to 70 cm. Replace it with fresh topsoil or specialized rose soil. Mix in plenty of well-aged compost (at least 2 years old). Apply a light organic starter fertilizer—horn shavings or dried cattle manure (250 g/m²).  
  • Maintain a safe distance: Alternatively, you can plant the new rose at a minimum distance of 50 cm from the old location. 


CAUTION: Under no circumstances should you mix large amounts of the old, depleted soil with healthy garden soil. Otherwise, you risk spreading the problem to previously unaffected areas of your garden.